Thursday, October 5, 2017

City Councils: the Finances

The characters in THE MINUTES don't discuss money matters in detail, but the city council likely makes a salary (something that has proven controversial across the US) and balances the budget of Big Cherry.

In smaller, more decentralized city councils, management of the budget generally falls to a committee of the council (rather than a manager or financial officer). This usually doesn't work out particularly well -- the committee estimates costs based on their limited knowledge, and members may prioritize their political concerns over the run-of-the-mill city expenses. While inefficient, this often poses no major problems in smaller cities where the margin of error is relatively small. (Read more in Budget Making for Small Cities.)

The average salary of city council members varies widely. In Shakopee, MN, the mayor makes around $15,000 a year, while in St. Cloud, MN, the mayor makes about $50,000. The salary of council members ranges as well, but generally holds at around $200 to $400 less per month than the mayor. Salaries for city officials are a controversial topic. Some view the position as public service, and find the council's ability to raise its own salary to be distasteful. Others argue that, by not making the council positions a living wage, it limits the pool of those who run for office to more affluent citizens.

Check out this article for more information on city council salaries in Minnesota.

City Councils: Basic Procedure & Closed Meetings

There is an intricate system of rules and procedures in place for city council meetings, based in part on the system of recording set down in the minutes. These regulations vary city by city, but a basic outline of council practices is outlined below.

Regular city council meetings take place at the same time and place every week, and usually have a set end time. In order for a meeting to occur, there must be a quorum (generally speaking, the quorum of a council with more than five members is two-thirds of the council). During a meeting, council members have a duty to vote as elected officials, except in case of conflict of interest.

City council meetings are organized around an agenda, usually a more detailed form of the list below:
  • Call to Order
  • Invocation
  • Pledge of Allegiance
  • Roll Call
  • Approval of Agenda
  • Special Guests & Presentations
  • Councilmember Reports
  • Mayor's Report
  • Proclamations
  • Public Comments & Hearings
  • Unfinished Business
  • New Business
  • Public Comments
  • Administrative Reports
  • Adjournment
Meetings and meeting minutes must be available to the public, except in case of a closed meeting. The minutes of a closed meeting must be kept for at least a year and a day, and be released in case of a pending lawsuit or civil action. In the state of Minnesota, the law requires that a meeting be closed if misconduct allegations are under discussion. In addition, a meeting may be closed for the following reasons:

  • Labor negotiations
  • Performance evaluations
  • Attorney-client privilege
  • Purchase/sale of property
  • Security reports

For a detailed description of the ins-and-outs of a council meeting, check out the Rules of Procedure for Municipal Councils. For a specific example of meeting procedures, see the procedures of the City of Petoskey, MI. And for several different examples and guides, see the Municipal Resources and Services Center.




City Councils: The Minutes

Ellen Wiese, Literary Apprentice

The minutes, unsurprisingly, play a central role in THE MINUTES. Peel, Johnson, Superba, and the council in general frequently orient their conversations and arguments around the mysterious October 25th minutes and what has (or has not) been done with them. See below for a general guide on the functions minutes serve, why they're important, and how Johnson would go about recording and distributing them in an ordinary circumstance.

The purpose of council meeting minutes is twofold: first, to maintain an impartial, reliable record of issues discussed and decisions made at the meeting; and second, to keep everyone on the council (especially those who can't attend) informed about what's happening on a week-by-week basis.

Care of the minutes is the primary role of the council clerk. The University of Western Australia writes, "You can look on it as a kind of transformational magic, whereby you make a silk purse from a sow's ear!" (full article here). As Johnson says, "It's needed" (3).

In general, good minutes do the following:

  • Focus on what has been decided and who is going to implement it.
    • "Mr. Blake proposed an attraction called 'Lincoln Smackdown.' Some discussion about the attraction followed and Mr. Blake agreed to develop the idea further before reintroducing it to the group" (65).
  • Includes only the necessary information.
    • This includes the names of speakers and a synopsis of their comments
    • Not all remarks are recorded. A council member can indicate that they want a specific point in the minutes with the phrase, "For the record."
  • Keep track of motions moved during the meeting, including any that were amended or canceled.
  • Record all votes taken and the outcome.
    • If it passes: "RESOLVED (8:3)"
    • If it does not pass, the text, "The motion was put and lost (7:4)" is included
  • Use simple past tense.
    • "The council recited the Pledge of Allegiance" (64).
  • Use impersonal, professional language.
    • "The discussion grew passionate, as some members of the council accused Mr. Carp of taking an unfriendly view of the heritage festival" (65).
  • Stay as succinct as possible while remaining accurate.
  • Maintain a consistent style, formality, and notation system.
  • Are massaged and edited by the clerk after the fact. For example, the clerk may note points made on both sides, even if one person dominated the conversation.
After the meeting is over, the clerk is responsible for finalizing a copy of the minutes and distributing them to all council members. In the next council session, the minutes will be brought before the council for approval, after which they must be open to the public -- unless the council meeting was in closed session (as in the case of the October 25th meeting). The clerk then maintains a copy of the minutes for a given period of time: open minutes will be available online or in the newspaper, while closed minutes are confidential and may be accessed for purposes of potential litigation.

The clerk may be called upon to read out the minutes if there is some debate about what was said at a previous meeting -- as is the case with Blake and Hanratty's disagreement over the discussion of the Lincoln Smackdown.


For an informational guide on the business and logistics of city council meetings, see the Information Memo: Meetings of City Councils from the League of Minnesota Cities.

For a detailed guide to recording and disseminating minutes (as well as many other useful administrative tidbits), see the Governance section of the University of Western Australia website.

For a detailed template of minutes for an academic council meeting, see the minutes template downloaded at this link. (Note: these minutes are intended for use at university meetings, not city councils.)

For comprehensive city protocols, see the City of Mt. Shasta City Council Protocols.