Thursday, October 12, 2017

Game Theory: Aspects & Overview

Regina Victor
10/12/17
Game Theory: Aspects & Overview

“Game theory.  If Breeding jumps on it.  If you bring up Carp and Breeding pounces on it, then you know they’re lying in wait.  Laying, lying.” – Blake in THE MINUTES, p. 17.

This article is an attempt to define Game Theory and its various aspects, and to relate those to the strategies of characters in THE MINUTES.

Game Theory is the study of strategy, there are players and “games”. However, the definition of games can be quite largely applied to any challenge, from chess, to board meetings, to war and imprisonment. Interdependence is the link between all of these events – every move you make is dependent on the moves and thoughts of another person or player.

Zero-sum Game: A game in which there must be one loser and one winner, “one player’s gain is always another’s loss.” This could be applied to things like war, one person must win the battle at great detriment to the losing side.

Interdependence: As stated above, interdependence means that every person’s move is dependent on another player’s actions, or perceived probable actions. There are two types of strategic interdependence within a game, sequential and simultaneous. In sequential games, the moves happen in a sequence and you are aware of what has come before you, like in a board game where you take turns. A simultaneous game is more like what the council members are playing in THE MINUTES, they are all acting at the same time, with their best guesses, and have no idea what anyone else’s agenda may be. Even though they are not aware of what other people’s agendas are, they do know that these agendas exist and they must attempt to plan for them. Therefore, a player must make a calculated action based off of the information they know about each player and attempt to move in their best interests. Players do not have to be hyperrational and can be spiteful, charitable, or a whole other host of human emotions, and for this reason it is important to put yourself in an opponents’ shoes when strategizing which move they might make.

The Prisoner’s Dilemma: Two suspects are questioned separately, and each can confess or keep silent. If suspect A keeps silent, then suspect B can get a better deal by confessing. If A confesses, B had better confess to avoid especially harsh treatment. Confession is B’s dominant strategy. The same is true for A. Therefore, in equilibrium both confess. Both would fare better if they both stayed silent. Such cooperative behavior can be achieved in repeated plays of the game because the temporary gain from cheating (confession) can be outweighed by the long-run loss due to the breakdown of cooperation. Strategies such as tit-for-tat are suggested in this context.”

Mixing Moves: You want to keep your opponent on their toes, because repeated strategies will allow them to subvert you. Sports is a good analogy here – you want to pump fake and break ankles every now and again so your shot doesn’t get blocked. Or, if you’re a cubs fan, sometimes you gotta bunt and run instead of going for the distance hit. Or if you’re Carp, maybe you should go straight to the news instead of talking to the guys who are definitely going to disappear you. I would think they may have strategies for people that come to them with any kind of truth…  

Strategic Moves: These usually take the form of threats or promises to influence other players. These moves will cause other players to not want to make harmful moves toward that person. An example of this within THE MINUTES is the final speeches that Superba makes, “Your little girl, Justine?  Don’t you consider the world you’re making for her?” This is a direct threat on Justine’s existence, and Superba is attempting to create circumstances via this threat that make it impossible for Peel to move against him.

Brinkmanship: another form of threat, where you literally try to bring your opponent to the brink of their endurance. In the sense of protests, riots can be used to try and bring the authoritarian regime to the brink so they will finally give in to rioters’ demands. Peel and Carp hope that by disrupting the meeting and threatening to take the story of the massacre to the news, that they can disrupt the proceedings enough to create their desired outcome: the council’s accountability for their actions.

Dominant and Dominated Strategy: Dominant strategy represents the best choice for the player no matter what the other players do. A Dominated strategy is when a choice is going to create a negative outcome for the player no matter what other players do.

Concealing and revealing information: Knowledge is power, especially when you can control it. Concealing information, as they do with Big Cherry’s history, is beneficial to Mayor Superba and the other city council members. Revealing information can be equally valuable if the player controls it, Blake suggests that they reveal the massacre at Big Cherry, but after the festival and with credible sources. “To conceal information, mix your moves. Bluffing in poker, for example, must not be systematic. Recall Winston Churchill’s dictum of hiding the truth in a “bodyguard of lies.” To convey information, use an action that is a credible “signal,” something that would not be desirable if the circumstances were otherwise. For example, an extended warranty is a credible signal to the consumer that the firm believes it is producing a high-quality product.”

Library of Economics and Liberty – “Game Theory” by Avinash Dixit and Barry Nalebuff http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/GameTheory.html


No comments:

Post a Comment